Introduction

Ever walked into a room and felt like something was missing? Chances are, it’s the little details—like a perfectly placed throw pillow—that can transform a space from “meh” to “wow.” Small throw pillows, especially the 8x8 size, are like the cherry on top of your decor sundae. They’re compact, versatile, and pack a punch when it comes to adding personality and comfort to your couch, chair, or bed. But let’s be real: with so many options out there, finding the right one can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack.

That’s where I come in. I’ve spent hours testing and comparing five of the best small throw pillows on the market, so you don’t have to. Whether you’re after something plush and luxurious, vibrant and eye-catching, or just plain practical, I’ve got you covered. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly which pillow will make your space feel like home. Ready to get started? Let’s go!

Mini 8x8 Small Pillow Insert

First up, this 8x8 pillow insert is a total workhorse. It’s firm, well-stuffed, and holds its shape like a champ—perfect for throw pillows or even craft projects. The hypoallergenic polyester filling is a nice bonus if you’re sensitive to allergens. But fair warning: it’s a bit overstuffed, which can make squeezing it into certain covers a bit of a workout. Still, if you’re looking for something durable and reliable, this one’s a solid pick.

The quality is top-notch, and it arrived in perfect condition, which is always a win. Just double-check your measurements before buying—some folks found it smaller than expected.

Pros & Cons:

Check Price on Amazon

Plush and Durable Throw Pillow Inserts - 18 x 18 inches Set of 8

Okay, so these aren’t 8x8, but hear me out. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, this set of 8 is worth considering. They come vacuum-sealed, so you’ll need to toss them in the dryer for a quick fluff to get them to their full size. Once they’re fluffed, they fit snugly into 18-inch covers and give your couch or bed a cozy, lived-in look.

That said, they’re not the thickest pillows out there. If you’re after something super plush, you might want to keep looking. But for the price, they’re a great deal—especially if you’re decorating on a dime.

Pros & Cons:

Check Price on Amazon

MoonRest Pack of 4 - Square Pillow Insert Form Filled Synthetic Down Alternative

Now, if you’re after something a little fancier, these MoonRest inserts are where it’s at. They’ve got that soft, down-like feel without the allergens, and they’re perfect for creating that “choppable” look everyone’s obsessed with. Just be prepared to fluff them up after they arrive—they come vacuum-sealed, so they need a little TLC to reach their full potential.

The woven cotton cover adds a touch of durability, and the synthetic down filling is both hypoallergenic and easy to shape. My only gripe? They might not fill larger covers as much as you’d like, so sizing up could be a good idea.

Pros & Cons:

Check Price on Amazon

Mini 8x8 Small Crafting Pillow Insert (Pack of 10)

If you’re a crafting enthusiast, this 10-pack is a game-changer. The inserts are soft, durable, and hypoallergenic, making them perfect for all kinds of projects. Plus, getting 10 in one pack is a steal if you’re refreshing multiple pillows or working on a big DIY project.

They hold their shape well, even after repeated use, though they’re not quite as dense as some of the other options. Still, for the price and quantity, they’re hard to beat.

Pros & Cons:

Check Price on Amazon

MoonRest Down Alternative Square Pillow Insert

Last but not least, this MoonRest insert is a solid choice if you’re after something plush and hypoallergenic. It’s soft, holds its shape well, and fits perfectly into 8x8 covers. It’s not the fluffiest option out there, but it’s durable and affordable—great for everyday use.

Pros & Cons:

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the deal with the 2-2-1 pillow rule?

The 2-2-1 pillow rule is a simple trick to make your bed look like it belongs in a magazine. You use two standard sleeping pillows, two shams (those fancy decorative covers), and one accent pillow. It’s all about layering and creating a balanced, inviting look. Trust me, it works like a charm.

What’s the most popular throw pillow size?

The 18x18-inch pillow is the MVP of throw pillows. It’s versatile, fits most furniture, and looks just right. But if you’ve got a bigger couch or bed, a 20x20-inch pillow can add a little extra oomph.

Should my throw pillow cover match the insert size?

Yep, you’ll want your cover to match the insert size for a clean, polished look. If you’re going for a plush, overstuffed vibe, you can size down the cover by an inch or two. Just don’t go too big, or you’ll end up with a saggy pillow.

Final Thoughts

After testing all these pillows, here’s the lowdown:

• Best for Firmness and Durability: Mini 8x8 Small Pillow Insert
• Best for Softness and Plush Feel: MoonRest Down Alternative Square Pillow Insert
• Best for Crafting and Custom Projects: Mini 8x8 Small Crafting Pillow Insert (10-Pack)
• Best for Premium Quality and Aesthetic Appeal: MoonRest Pack of 4

No matter what you’re looking for, there’s a pillow here that’ll fit your needs. Happy decorating!

Affiliate Disclosure

Just a heads-up: as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you click on one of the links above and make a purchase, I may get a small commission at no extra cost to you. It’s a win-win—you get a great pillow, and I get to keep doing what I love. Thanks for your support!